4.38 Na hi jnanena sadrsam

Standard

4.38

Na hi jnanena sadrsam

Pavitram iha vidyate

Tat svayam yoga-samsiddhah

Kalenatmani vindati

Na hi jnanena sadrsam 

not (Na)

indeed (hi)

this knowledge gained here (jnanena)

Comparable to (sadrsam)

Pavitram iha vidyate

that which is scared to us (pavitram) in this world therefore  (iha — Telugu, Iha mariu)

is the learning undergone (vidyate)

Tat svayam yoga-samsiddhah

That (tat) done by yourself (svayam) — yoga (what our bodies must undergo) to be equally perfected.

Kalena atmani vindati

In course of time (Kalena — Telugu),   fulfills one’s soul (atmani),  is enjoyed (Vindati).

Iksvakave Full meaning:

Not indeed the knowledge gained here comparable to that which is sacred in this world, that is the learning undergone. That done by yourself is yoga-samsiddhah; the yoga that is to be equally perfected (the many forms of yoga as it applies to life). In the course of time what fulfills one’s soul and is enjoyed. Or in the course of time what one’s soul enjoys. 

What can I say, the way I read the verses it seems like what this is all about is the scripture of mankind, ones yoga. This is also one of my favorite verses. 

 

Prabhupada’s version:

http://vedabase.net/bg/4/38/en

In this world, there is nothing so sublime and pure as transcendental knowledge. Such knowledge is the mature fruit of all mysticism. And one who has become accomplished in the practice of devotional service enjoys knowledge within himself in due course of time.

What is transcendental knowledge —— something you can reach with your feet?

Transcendental knowledge is the mature fruit of all mysticism.  It does not say that in the verse. What is mysticism? —- smoke going up in the air?

When you become accomplished in practicing devotional service you enjoy knowledge with YOURself?  Of course you would, that is the Bhakti you have so naturally you would enjoy it with yourself. By the way there is no word for devotional service in the verse.

Sorry to say it does not make sense to me in the way it should be understood and I don’t believe it is the correct understanding.

Here is what was written in Tapasyanandas version. If you are looking for the gist of the meaning, this works too.

 

 

 

Now… let me ask you all this.

Why are the words jumbled up again to derive at the meaning? So it is no longer “na hi jnanena” but it is “na vidyate” to mean does not exist?

Is there a word for perfect in this worse? There is no word for perfect in this verse.

One who is perfect in yoga discovers IT in oneself overtime, the knowledge? This maybe valid, but what the verse means is knowledge gained here (in Gita) is not comparable to that which is sacred to us in this world the vidyate, or the education learning undergone.

 

About Iksvakave

I am on a quest to understand my religion --- Hinduism. I have decided to keep a log of my discoveries, and experiences and what I have come to learn in the process. I like to travel through people vicariously. To observe the working of the mind, body and spirit. And heart. The soul infact is what our bodies have and what we are ultimately or in the end! The pricelessness of the soul is a soul is only potentially divine. Our journey here is therefore to understand that divinity in our lives. The ideals of societies, language, culture religion, and spirituality, is what interests me. what we know and don't know and outside of our four walls, maybe the priceless truth of that journey here on earth also, our yoga to be learned and equally perfected in life. What this blog is about is the values of the mother tongue India. And the values and culture of India and my nationality America. Pricelessness of it one will come to know you see. The forehead, is the center of the Hindu conscious. veena kodali

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s